WCAG 2 is a free standard so many people do use it despite its many failings. But there are many other color contrast standards, WCAG 2 is only one of them.

Hi Kevin thank you for the reply,

There are in fact many color contrast standards, WCAG_2 is only one of them. Certainly, as it is a free standard, many people do use it despite its many failings. Among the failings is that WCAG_2.x can not calculate for dark mode at all. Further, WCAG_2.x does not identify middle contrast for self-illuminated displays, calculating reds and oranges so incorrectly that it is harmful to readability for color vision deficiencies such as protanopia. See: “What’s Red and Black and Not Read All Over”

ICC profiles are based around CIE XYZ or LAB. XYZ is used most often. CIELAB is used in ICC profiles when transforming from RGB to CMYK space, or back. CIELAB has a number of inaccuracies which OKLab helps to correct but OKLab does not "generate" an L* value; L* is a function of CIELAB or CIELUV, and is luminance-only (achromatic) derived from the Y of XYZ, Y is converted to a perceptual lightness that is based on Munsell Value. ∆L* gives results which are similar (but not identical) to WCAG_2 contrast, and therefore fails in similar ways.

The said, the following statements are somewhat troubling, as they indicate some misunderstandings regarding APCA, so I'd like to clarify.

Kevin stated: "…APCA is unable to capture enough variables to accurately measure readability/accessibility of humans in all scenarios…"

I get the sense you have not read the documentation for APCA or the APCA Readability Criterion. APCA is superior to WCAG2 in calculating readability contrast. And the APCA Readability Criterion provides for more than mere contrast measurement for guidelines on readable content.

Kevin stated: "…How does APCA measure the legibility between the use of either font?…"

This is conflating two completely separate features. And here, WCAG2 does absolutely nothing. APCA Readability Criterion on the other hand provides guidelines on the use and appropriate usage of different font faces and provides use-cases for fonts. In particular APCA defines reference fonts, while WCAG2 ignores these variations.

Kevin stated: "Would it matter greatly if we draw outside the lines of numbers/science (APCA/WCAG2) and rely on heuristics and qualitative data to make good decisions on color contrast?"

This is a very strange statement, and I don't know quite what you are trying to say. Perhaps you can further clarify what you mean? Because it does matter greatly when people ignore the science of human perception, and such assertions are part of the problem. Heuristics and qualitative data are part of the scientific method, yet you are making a statement that is simultaneously dismissing science and calling for trial and error (heuristics)? Absent good research protocols, that leads to confirmation bias, which is a principal problem in WCAG 2.x.

In terms of creating guidelines, actual science—meaning study and research, and particularly across/in consideration of visual impairments, and ample user testing—is what is both reasonable and what leads to useable, stable guidelines.

Proactive Information

Kevin, can you tell me where or who led you to believe some of these things that you've stated? I recognize there are some individuals spreading false and misleading information, for reasons unknown. It would be good to put a stop to it.

Thank you for reading,

Andy

Andrew Somers
Myndex Research
W3C Invited Expert

Opinions are my own and do not necessarily reflect those of the W3C.
The facts on the other hand are a matter of prima facie evidence.

Supporting article with references:
“The Realities And Myths Of Contrast And Color”

A painting or close-up of a woman's face in her hair is extremely colorful and filled with small buildings
“Color is on my mind” by Author and MidJourney

Reply to Kevin: Color Genome Thread was originally published in Tangled Web on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.