Response to: “Experiments in simulating colorblindness”, with followup questions.

A surreal painting of a rainbow eyeball in the style of Salvador Dali

Hello Eric,

I found your article very interesting as I am researching color vision for accessibility. I have some questions for you and some thoughts.

QUESTION: What color model were you using regarding hue “angle”? As color itself does not have an angle only some color models do — and the various color models vary greatly in uniformity/spacing around a “hue wheel” is this CIELAB LCh?

CIELAB LCh for instance is significantly different in terms of how hues are mapped to an “angle” vs HSL or HSV, so I am wondering if it’s LAB LCh? I say this partly due to the bunching up at what is labeled as “-1”, and there is definately non-uniformity in LAB LCh around purples/blues for trichromats as well — part of the non-uniformity issues with that space.

In terms of perception, I’ve also been wondering if dichromats have functioning opponent processes, or how or if that plays a significant role in terms of perception for dichromats — though I’m not sure how this could be tested. But I do see the bunching up around -3, which makes me think about how that might be a factor.

QUESTION: have you toyed with more advanced models like CIECAM02 could be used to model or predict protan or deutan CVD — I would really like to be able to accurately model how protan or deutan “see” a tristimulus monitor, specifically sRGB.

And finally: on a standard sRGB monitor, what effect does the Green color primary have for you? how much difference do you perceive if you set the Green channel to 0? How much does it affect your perception of luminance? Have you ever tried blending the Green channel with the Red and/or Blue?

Thank you,

Andy


Examining Colorblindness was originally published in Tangled Web on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.