What does it mean to get something right, if the underlying foundation of that thing is ultimately wrong?

Bashed up and smashed up old cars strewn across the barren land
Bashed up old cars… can they be repaired? Does it make sense to start with a new paint job? Image by author and MJAI

Hi Lucas,

A good article on how to get WCAG 2 contrast right. Unfortunately, WCAG 2 contrast does not promote actual accessibility, and when developed did not consider the wealth of research into critical contrast as applies to reading available at the time.

As such "getting WCAG 2 contrast right" is a somewhat spurious goal, and following it to-the-letter can be harmful to readability for many, or even most users, depending on context.

Comparison of dark mode contrast minimum's for WCAG and APCA.
As for legal, which one would you rather defend in court? Image by author

WCAG 2 contrast references an obsolete 1988 standard that related to green or amber and black (monochrome) CRTs displaying matrix text (on/off). To say that has no relevance to today is an understatement.

That WCAG 2 is being elevated to law in some regions is unfortunate per the areas where that voluntary guideline is lacking veracity. And the contrast SCs are where it is indeed most fallacious.

Fortunately in the United States, even the US Access Board's 508 rule (which applies only to governmental sites) has wide exceptions—including for alternate facilitation. This means that modern design guidelines such as APCA Readability Criterion are perfectly useable instead of WCAG 2 for this context, as these newer guidelines reference peer-reviewed scientific consensus and promote actual accessibility.

While the article lists copious references, nearly all of them are to the same W3C documents or circular references back to those documents. Documents which have engendered an egregious misunderstanding throughout the accessibility and design communities. Continued promotion of these obsolete misunderstandings only serves to increase the divisive cognitive dissonance surrounding the subject matter.

It is probably useful to point out that some of the graphics intended to demonstrate WCAG 2 are not actually doing so. Take this graphic, which in the article used bold and higher contrast letters to depict 4.5:1, but the actual 4.5:1 is much less. Here is that same graphic revised with contrast adjusted to depict what it wasy it is. Here shown along side another contrast method:

A redo of the graphic that was supposed to portray 4.5{1 contrast but was in fact portraying a much much higher contrast than 4.5 to 1. Here the original contrast has been lined out, with replacements above it which are technically correct in terms of the actual contrast they portray
Here the original contrast has been lined out, with replacements above it which are technically correct in terms of the actual contrast they portray.

As can be seen, when actually using WCAG 2.x contrast math (lower lines), darker colors become difficult to read. the upper three lines are using another contrast metric that is perceptually uniform.

Thank you for reading,

Andrew Somers
W3C WAI Invited Expert
Visual Contrast Research Lead
--
Director of Research,
Inclusive Reading Technologies, Inc.
A non-profit consortium dedicated to improving readability and visual accessibility for all.

Opinions expressed are the author’s and may not represent those of W3C/WAI.


Getting the Wrong, Right? was originally published in Tangled Web on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.